Booktalk this now: THE HATE U GIVE by Angie Thomas

The story behind the story.  I received an early review copy of this book when I attended the ALA Mid-Winter meetings in January and asked extra-nicely at the HarperCollins booth if there were extras.  


(Pro tip: Check to see if there are any ALA meetings happening near you and block those days off on your calendar now.  Free books.  Lots of them.)


I started reading it about 6:10 AM over breakfast before leaving for school.  By about 6:50 AM I was reluctant to leave the house and get to school.


The book talk. I told students that this was the rare book that made literally want to drop everything and read.  Starr is at a spring break party when gunshots go off and she and childhood friend Khalil leave the party by car in search of safety.  Police pull Starr and Khalil over and end up killing Khalil in what might be a case of mistaken identity.


Why do you think the cops had reason to be suspicious of Khalil?  I asked.


Students responded:

Well, he’s a teenager and the people who were at the party were teenagers too.

He was near the scene of the crime when it happened.

Was he speeding away when cops pulled him over ?  (The book makes it clear: he wasn’t speeding.)

Was he black?


That’s when I covered up all but the first letters of the acrostic so students could read the title down the page: The Hate U Give or THUG.  


“Ohhhhhhh,” students said.  “Khalil was probably stereotyped because he looked like a thug.”


Building empathy and understanding for the Black Lives Matter movement.  While this book covers a lot of tough teen topics, be ready for readers to proke, prod, and question its support of Black Lives Matter.


Be ready for readers to say, “What about all the cops that keep everybody safe?  You can’t be anti-cop.”  And “I don’t understand why Black Lives Matter people have to make it about black people.  What about white people who just want everybody to get along?”  Thomas pre-emptively responds to these readers by giving this book a strong moral core, where there are supportive police officers, kind family members, a grassroots nonviolent community organization, and a terrific white boyfriend along with some villain characters of both races.  


Starr is a teenager of the moment.  She’s a tumblr addict, she wants you to know that she considers Beyonce a cousin, she nae-naes and hits the quan.  She embodies contemporary teens in general and contemporary black teens in particular.  In 25 years she’ll appear fuddy-duddy, just as her Jodeci and Juvenile-loving parents are right now.


Patience and stamina.  The action happens in the first few dozen pages, and what follows is reaction and rebuilding.  This book felt more slowly paced to me than readalike All-American Boys by Jason Reynolds and Brendan Kiely.  Some readers, particularly middle school readers, might find the pace discouraging, so if you include this in a classroom, I’d recommend that readers find a book partner to talk about the book as they read.  


Where to buy it.  You can buy signed copies from Lemuria Books in Jackson, Mississippi.  The book goes on sale tomorrow!


Amy Estersohn is an English teacher in New York.  There are as many seasons of Survivor as there are books in her To Be Read pile.   Follow her on Twitter @HMX_MSE


3 thoughts on “Booktalk this now: THE HATE U GIVE by Angie Thomas

  1. kenneth greco August 24, 2017 at 7:24 pm Reply

    Teaching a ninth grade class in the Bronx- do you think this book could work as a whole class novel, or is it better as a choice in book clubs, or for possible independent reading? I want to employ more of the workshop model this year while still teaching ~2-3 core novels or plays. Thank you!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Amy Estersohn August 24, 2017 at 7:43 pm Reply

      Kenneth – we’re practically neighbors!

      My gut says you should read aloud the first 20 ish pages with the class and then play a go-see from there. This is not a book you want to over-sell to readers; let them find their own way into it.

      Also you should totally look into Adam Silvera’s books, specifically MORE HAPPY THAN NOT. Adam’s a Bronx kid through and though and he writes about the Bronx. Bruckner Boulevard and all. Lilliam Riviera also has a book – THE EDUCATION OF MARGOT SANCHEZ – I think Margot lives in Riverdale and works at her family store in Kingsbridge. Interesting lens there.

      Thanks for your question,

      (who fanatically reads YA that takes place in the non-Brooklyn outer boroughs)


  2. Karry Dornak February 27, 2017 at 7:07 am Reply

    So cool to see this on the blog today! I just picked it up this weekend. I’m only a few chapters in, but I am HOOKED. I brought it to school with me this morning so I can book talk it to my students.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Karry Dornak Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: