I Prefer a Community of Confident Writers — Our Jump into Understanding a Writer’s Craft


Before spring term was over, I’d written two pages of notes in the back cover of my writer’s notebook. I titled it “Remember to Do Things to do Differently.” I’m a bit ambitious — and I realize, often, too hard on myself. Although I knew my students learned last yearemember-to-do-things-differentlyr, I wasn’t confident that they couldn’t have learned more.

I imagine you’ve been there, too. Always second guessing.

One of the things I knew I needed to improve was my relationships with students — I needed them to be good and strong, faster.  I also needed to help students jump in quicker to the complexities of craft analysis without scaring the poor little dears.

So last week, the second week of school, I did what Lisa just wrote about yesterday. I “Encourage[d] Students to Start Sharing Who They Are,” and I did it by sharing a favorite poem by Wislawa Szymborska: “Possibilities.”

I asked students to study the poet’s language in each line and then write their own “Possibilities” poem, imitating the poet’s sentence structure and word play. I gave them a copy of my annotations and wrote my own poem as a model.

This proved to be an excellent lead into the rhetorical analysis students must be able to do in AP Language. I was able to see which students quickly understood how to look closely at an author’s craft — and which ones did not.

The best part though was what I learned about my students. All their preferences!!

Last Friday, when their poems were due, we did our first Author’s Chair share in class.

First, to help students build confidence, they read their poems to a partner.



Then, volunteers sat in our Author’s Chair and read their poems to the class.

While the student read his poem, everyone else sat with sticky note and pen in hand ready to offer “blessings,” things they liked about the author’s use of language, or connections they could make to his ideas.


After each writer shared, the class flooded him with “blessings.” Smiles grew wide, trust blossomed, and the community that I felt was missing for too long a time last year took root.readingblessings

Bonus:  When students read their little notes, carefully crafted by peers who listened to
their writing, their confidence as writers grew. Too bad we ran out of class time. I might have run out of sticky notes if all students would have felt the desire to share.


I wouldn’t have minded.

I would not have minded at all.


I would love to hear your ideas on building community and/or introducing students to rhetorical analysis. Please join the conversation and share in the comments.


Tagged: , , , , ,

3 thoughts on “I Prefer a Community of Confident Writers — Our Jump into Understanding a Writer’s Craft

  1. Try it Tuesday:Workshop Thievery | September 27, 2016 at 7:41 am Reply

    […] Try it Tuesday matches (snatches) Amy’s Blessings Cards (or an even more detailed and awesome Blessing Card Mini -Lesson here) with Shana’s […]


  2. […] another class period, I had students read, analyze, and then emulate Amy’s recent suggestion of the poem “Possibilities.” This was the first year I used this poem during this unit, and I could not be more happy with the […]


  3. shanakarnes September 7, 2016 at 8:58 am Reply

    Awwwww! This post gave me the happiest kind of chills–you know the one, where you read something beautiful and get goosebumps on your arm even as you grin from ear to ear. Your writing often has that effect on me. ❤

    What I love about this idea–one that was doubtless one of your flashes of quick inspiration–is that it is a fantastic blend of formative assessment as well as community-building. You learned about your students, and they learned about one another, language, and collaboration. They also learned about you, and that you value all of those things. What a powerful lesson to teach early on, to help set the tone of work and discovery and growth and sharing that will be a hallmark of your students' learning this year.

    Don't forget that you're an amazing teacher, not only because you are constantly asking yourself how you can improve, but also because the work you do every day is good work. Keep at it, great lady.

    Liked by 1 person

What are you thinking?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: